| 1 | J. EastwoodGoalkeeper | Cambridge United | 29 | +45.3 24/25→25/26 | 47▲3484.6% | 26▲18% |
| 2 | A. DrinanCentre-forward | Swindon Town | 28 | +41 24/25→25/26 | 52▲376.1% | 28▲4.4% |
| 3 | D. DanielsCentre-back | Oldham | 32 | +38.5 24/25→25/26 | 41▲1750% | 16▲18.1% |
| 4 | M. SheltonDefensive midfielder | Barnet | 29 | +37 22/23→25/26 | 44▲506.8% | 24▼6.2% |
| 5 | E. MontheCentre-back | Oldham | 31 | +35.5 23/24→25/26 | 44▲427.7% | 20▼32.1% |
| 6 | D. KanuCentre-forward | Walsall | 21 | +34.2 24/25→25/26 | 38▲1036.4% | 37▼16.9% |
| 7 | S. BraybrookeDefensive midfielder | Chesterfield | 22 | +32.3 24/25→25/26 | 35▲1404.3% | 36▼6.3% |
| 8 | K. WattsCentre-back | Cambridge United | 26 | +31.7 24/25→25/26 | 44▲255.6% | 35▼17.4% |
| 9 | T. O'ReillyAttacking midfielder | Crewe | 22 | +30.8 24/25→25/26 | 36▲581.1% | 38▼6.2% |
| 10 | S. SwinkelsCentre-back | Chesterfield | 22 | +30.1 24/25→25/26 | 38▲376.3% | 38▼12.4% |
| 11 | T. PettCentral midfielder | Oldham | 34 | +29.9 24/25→25/26 | 34▲808.1% | 12▲30.9% |
| 12 | C. VernamAttacking midfielder | Grimsby | 29 | +28.6 24/25→25/26 | 36▲408.6% | 24±0% |
| 13 | B. KnightAttacking midfielder | Cambridge United | 24 | +28.1 21/22→25/26 | 29▲2554.5% | 36▼6.5% |
| 14 | N. KabambaCentre-forward | Bromley | 33 | +25.5 24/25→25/26 | 30▲531.3% | 12±0% |
| 15 | A. ReadDefensive midfielder | Colchester | 27 | +25.5 24/25→25/26 | 44▲137.1% | 30▼1.3% |
| 16 | S. ClucasCentral midfielder | Shrewsbury | 35 | +25.3 24/25→25/26 | 31▲477.4% | 11▲2.9% |
| 17 | M. EkpitetaFull-back | Milton Keynes Dons | 30 | +25 24/25→25/26 | 37▲210.1% | 22▼28.2% |
| 18 | A. CharlesDefensive midfielder | Bromley | 27 | +24.8 24/25→25/26 | 40▲159% | 30▲1.3% |
| 19 | E. TezgelCentre-forward | Crewe | 20 | +24.4 24/25→25/26 | 24 | 34▼40.5% |
| 20 | K. McFadzeanCentre-back | Chesterfield | 39 | +23.4 24/25→25/26 | 30▲334.3% | 9▲172.7% |
| 21 | C. MacGillivrayGoalkeeper | Milton Keynes Dons | 33 | +23.1 24/25→25/26 | 26▲721.9% | 16▲34.5% |
| 22 | C. PatersonCentre-forward | Milton Keynes Dons | 31 | +23 24/25→25/26 | 43▲115% | 19▼51.7% |
| 23 | J. WilliamsCentral midfielder | Crawley Town | 25 | +22.7 24/25→25/26 | 28▲445.1% | 32▼19.1% |
| 24 | W. HondermarckCentral midfielder | Bromley | 25 | +22.1 24/25→25/26 | 32▲232.6% | 35▼15.2% |
| 25 | R. StauntonFull-back | Grimsby | 24 | +21.9 20/21→25/26 | 27▲421.2% | 34▲11.1% |
| 26 | J. GibbonsFull-back | Cambridge United | 28 | +21.9 24/25→25/26 | 39▲131.1% | 27▼25.7% |
| 27 | M. Fondop-TalumCentre-forward | Oldham | 32 | +21.8 21/22→25/26 | 26▲473.9% | 15▼29.4% |
| 28 | O. LuntCentral midfielder | Crewe | 21 | +21.1 24/25→25/26 | 23▲1110.5% | 34▲17.8% |
| 29 | J. SmithGoalkeeper | Grimsby | 24 | +20.8 24/25→25/26 | 22▲1890.9% | 32▲12.5% |
| 30 | A. KilgourFull-back | Bristol Rovers | 28 | +20.7 24/25→25/26 | 25▲440.4% | 26▼24.1% |
| 31 | J. GordonCentre-forward | Barrow | 31 | +20.4 24/25→25/26 | 23▲784.6% | 16▼7.6% |
| 32 | T. LeighDefensive midfielder | Bristol Rovers | 26 | +19.9 24/25→25/26 | 27▲280.3% | 29▼1.4% |
| 33 | J. AusterfieldCentral midfielder | Salford City | 24 | +19.7 24/25→25/26 | 28▲243.2% | 33▲9.5% |
| 34 | H. McKirdyCentre-forward | Crawley Town | 29 | +19.5 24/25→25/26 | 24▲475.6% | 21▼5.8% |
| 35 | A. MayorDefensive midfielder | Cambridge United | 21 | +19.5 24/25→25/26 | 20 | 35▲15% |
| 36 | J. RobsonFull-back | Oldham | 28 | +19.3 23/24→25/26 | 50▲62.3% | 28▼11.1% |
| 37 | Ethan EnnisAttacking midfielder | Fleetwood Town | 21 | +18.8 24/25→25/26 | 22▲522.2% | 35▲12.7% |
| 38 | Z. HemmingGoalkeeper | Chesterfield | 26 | +18.3 24/25→25/26 | 23▲381.3% | 31▼27.5% |
| 39 | J. TomkinsonFull-back | Cheltenham | 24 | +18.2 24/25→25/26 | 27▲209.2% | 32▼20.8% |
| 40 | L. AppéréCentre-forward | Cambridge United | 27 | +17.5 24/25→25/26 | 22▲388.9% | 28▼25.7% |
| 41 | Z. MedleyFull-back | Fleetwood Town | 26 | +17.1 24/25→25/26 | 20▲633.3% | 27▼0.7% |
| 42 | L. KellyDefensive midfielder | Milton Keynes Dons | 30 | +17 24/25→25/26 | 39▲78.7% | 22▼1.3% |
| 43 | T. BarkhuizenCentral midfielder | Barrow | 33 | +16.9 24/25→25/26 | 17 | 10▼53.5% |
| 44 | S. KaikaiAttacking midfielder | Cambridge United | 30 | +16.6 24/25→25/26 | 28▲146.9% | 21▼26.7% |
| 45 | H. ForsterCentral midfielder | Crawley Town | 26 | +16.4 24/25→25/26 | 27▲153.3% | 30▼28.1% |
| 46 | A. SmithCentre-back | Gillingham | 24 | +16.3 24/25→25/26 | 28▲140.5% | 32▲11.8% |
| 47 | J. SparkesFull-back | Bristol Rovers | 26 | +16.1 24/25→25/26 | 24▲206.4% | 31▼27.7% |
| 48 | O. NorburnDefensive midfielder | Notts County | 33 | +15.9 24/25→25/26 | 22▲283.9% | 12▼39.3% |
| 49 | W. BoyleCentre-back | Shrewsbury | 30 | +15.9 23/24→25/26 | 32▲100.6% | 21▼20.8% |
| 50 | Charlie Jay WhitakerAttacking midfielder | Tranmere | 22 | +15.7 24/25→25/26 | 29▲114.6% | 34▲2.8% |