| 1 | S. AndersonFull-back | Hartford Athletic | 24 | +19.3 24/25→25/26 | 23▲551.4% | 33▼15.9% |
| 2 | S. DjeffalDefensive midfielder | New Mexico United | 27 | +17.4 23/24→25/26 | 19▲915.8% | 27▼23.6% |
| 3 | J. GurrCentral midfielder | Sacramento Republic | 30 | +17 21/22→25/26 | 19▲1062.5% | 18▼51.2% |
| 4 | D. TrejoCentral midfielder | Oakland Roots | 28 | +16.1 24/25→25/26 | 18▲1073.3% | 22▼18% |
| 5 | D. CrisostomoDefensive midfielder | Sacramento Republic | 29 | +15.8 23/24→25/26 | 18▲790% | 22▼28.8% |
| 6 | F. ValotCentre-forward | Oakland Roots | 33 | +15.3 21/22→25/26 | 20▲318.8% | 14▼39.9% |
| 7 | N. OkelloCentral midfielder | Lexington | 26 | +14.7 22/23→25/26 | 18▲420% | 28▼17.2% |
| 8 | L. HaakensonAttacking midfielder | San Antonio | 29 | +14.6 23/24→25/26 | 16▲858.8% | 23▼33% |
| 9 | A. McFaddenCentral midfielder | Louisville City | 28 | +13.4 22/23→25/26 | 19▲235.1% | 27▼25.5% |
| 10 | R. DoghmanFull-back | Orange County SC | 29 | +9.9 22/23→25/26 | 11▲825% | 21▼35.4% |
| 11 | E. PerezAttacking midfielder | Louisville City | 27 | +8.7 21/22→25/26 | 15▲150% | 27▼27.6% |
| 12 | K. BurksCentre-back | Lexington | 26 | +8.2 23/24→25/26 | 14▲151.9% | 29▼16.7% |
| 13 | E. KizzaCentre-forward | Indy Eleven | 27 | +7.6 21/22→25/26 | 10▲281.5% | 25▼36.3% |
| 14 | N. HämäläinenFull-back | New Mexico United | 29 | +6.2 22/23→25/26 | 10▲163.2% | 22▼40.2% |
| 15 | A. MabikaCentre-back | Rhode Island | 28 | +6.2 24/25→25/26 | 10▲151.2% | 21▼38.1% |
| 16 | R. DamusCentre-forward | Birmingham Legion | 27 | +5.8 22/23→25/26 | 30▲24.2% | 30▼13.4% |
| 17 | T. PasherCentral midfielder | Birmingham Legion | 32 | +5.7 22/23→25/26 | 17▲51.8% | 12▼55.1% |
| 18 | L. KettererGoalkeeper | Lexington | 32 | +5.5 21/22→25/26 | 8▲203.7% | 12▼55.3% |
| 19 | A. WattsDefensive midfielder | Loudoun United | 26 | +5.4 24/25→25/26 | 18▲42.9% | 36▼3.2% |
| 20 | K. Hernández-FosterCentral midfielder | Detroit City | 24 | +5.3 23/24→25/26 | 11▲100% | 29▼24.4% |
| 21 | K. McIntoshGoalkeeper | Oakland Roots | 32 | +4.6 23/24→25/26 | 10▲79.3% | 14▼42.7% |
| 22 | P. WilsonCentre-forward | Oakland Roots | 29 | +4.2 23/24→25/26 | 8▲107.7% | 19▼21.8% |
| 23 | A. StanleyCentral midfielder | Detroit City | 26 | +4.1 21/22→25/26 | 5▲683.3% | 26▼29.2% |
| 24 | L. MelanoCentral midfielder | Miami FC | 33 | +3.8 21/22→25/26 | 14▲35.8% | 10▼67.9% |
| 25 | M. KayeDefensive midfielder | Sacramento Republic | 31 | +3.2 24/25→25/26 | 17▲23.2% | 18▼24.4% |
| 26 | M. RealFull-back | Hartford Athletic | 27 | +2.4 23/24→25/26 | 11▲28.9% | 24▼36.5% |
| 27 | C. GlosterCentre-back | New Mexico United | 26 | +2.2 22/23→25/26 | 8▲36.7% | 27▼35.3% |
| 28 | N. CampisiGoalkeeper | Tampa Bay Rowdies | 29 | +1.2 24/25→25/26 | 1 | 20▼48% |
| 29 | D. BadjiCentre-forward | Phoenix Rising | 33 | +0.8 24/25→25/26 | 5▲21.1% | 12▼15.6% |
| 30 | L. WykeCentre-back | Tampa Bay Rowdies | 30 | +0.5 20/21→25/26 | 6▲8.5% | 21▼43.7% |
| 31 | M. RomeroCentral midfielder | Miami FC | 30 | +0.4 22/23→25/26 | 15▲2.7% | 18▼55.6% |
| 32 | A. SkundrichCentral midfielder | Loudoun United | 31 | -0.3 22/23→25/26 | 10▼2.9% | 16▼50% |
| 33 | B. HamidGoalkeeper | Miami FC | 35 | -0.6 22/23→25/26 | 3▼15% | 9▼46.2% |
| 34 | M. PalominoCentral midfielder | Orange County SC | 25 | -0.9 24/25→25/26 | 13▼6.5% | 25▼5.3% |
| 35 | E. BartlowCentre-back | Tampa Bay Rowdies | 26 | -2 24/25→25/26 | 7▼47.8% | 33▼7.1% |
| 36 | Miguel BerryCentre-forward | Charleston Battery | 29 | -6.1 24/25→25/26 | 6▼51.7% | 27▼23.4% |
| 37 | G. SmithCentre-back | Charleston Battery | 30 | -6.3 20/21→25/26 | 5▼54.3% | 16▼55.7% |
| 38 | N. GordonCentre-back | Monterey Bay | 24 | -7.6 21/22→25/26 | 5▼61.8% | 30▼50% |
| 39 | T. LeiboldFull-back | Sacramento Republic | 32 | -10 24/25→25/26 | 6▼61.3% | 17▼32.4% |
| 40 | S. LletgetCentral midfielder | Monterey Bay | 34 | -10 24/25→25/26 | 15▼39.7% | 16▼26.2% |
| 41 | T. BrewittCentre-back | Orange County SC | 29 | -10.9 23/24→25/26 | 5▼69.4% | 18▼31.6% |
| 42 | F. LassoCentre-back | Tampa Bay Rowdies | 33 | -16 22/23→25/26 | 1▼93% | 9▼60.6% |
| 43 | M. RodríguezCentral midfielder | Sacramento Republic | 30 | -25.4 24/25→25/26 | 5▼84.7% | 20▼37.1% |