
ratings updated 21 Oct 2026
Profile
Season stats
Full career & schedule →Domestic-league season · Doncaster.
Also this season
On loan at Stoke City — Championship: 15 apps, 0g 0a, 1350 min
On loan at Leyton Orient — EFL Trophy: 2 apps, 0g 0a, 180 min
On loan at Stoke City — FA Cup: 2 apps, 0g 0a, 180 min
The headline Season rating covers his time at Doncaster; availability counts only fixtures while in this squad.
Performance data · by competition
| Competition | Apps | Min | Match |
|---|---|---|---|
League Cup | 1 | 96 | 7.9 |
Scout report
Tommy Simkin is a 21-year-old goalkeeper at Doncaster, rated 43.6 overall by Field Insider's model, ranking 47th of 213 on scout potential in the League One and 635th of 1726 U-23 players tracked. A young player, he has been a rotation option this season (39.1% of available minutes). Below: strengths, watch-points, market-value outlook and the latest transfer news on Simkin.
Judged on this season alone, Simkin graded 14 — a solid campaign that ranks top 31% of the 23 goalkeepers in the League One, on 3 clean sheets across 9 appearances.
Year-on-year, that's a clear step up on last season (Season 9 → 14). Over the 4 seasons on record his form has trended upward, peaking in 2024/25.
On long-term talent our Rating reads 44, top 18% of the 23 goalkeepers in the League One. At 21 Simkin is still climbing toward his ceiling, and a market index of 8.8 reflects that trajectory.
Past his 2024/25 peak — the recent trend is downward, so buyers are paying for what's left, not what was.
Output in context · Doncaster finished 19th of 24 · a lower-table side
3 clean sheets in 9 appearances (33% of games). Keeping that many behind a lower-table side (19th of 24) — a side that concedes more — points to a busy, productive season between the posts.
Watch points
- Game time. Only 39.1% of available minutes — needs a settled run to prove the level.
- Level. Rates below a nailed-on top-tier starter on our model.
Outlook
With a Rating of 43.6, Simkin carries the 4th-highest potential of the goalkeepers in the League One of 23 — though on just 9 appearances this season, so the standing rests on a small sample. A rotation minutes keeper carrying the gloves this season. At 21 the trajectory points up — potential sits near its ceiling (97/100) and market value should climb as minutes and output follow.
Generated from Field Insider's rating model · AI-written analysis to follow.
Season statistics
Bars = where he ranks among goalkeepers in the League One with 600+ minutes this season.
Goalkeeping
Distribution
Yellow/red cards
Transfer news
No transfer news found for this player.










