Domestic-league season · New York City FC.
Missed 7 of New York City FC's ~39 games this season through 6 injury absences and 1 suspension (leg). He still appeared 29 times — a solid return given how little of the season he was available. His rating is judged mainly on the games he was fit to play.
| Competition | Apps | G | A | Min | Match |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Major League Soccer | 29 | 1 | 1 | 2336 | 6.88 |
 Leagues Cup | 3 | 0 | 0 | 180 | 7.05 |
O'Toole's current-season form is up 208% on last season (Season 12→37), while his Rating eased 43→36. That makes this his strongest season for form to date.
| Season | Club | Apps | G | A | Match | RTG | Season |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025/26 | New York City FC · 8th | 29 | 1 | 1 | 6.88 | 36 | 37 |
| 2024/25 | New York City FC · 6th | 34 | 1 | 2 | 6.88 | 43 | 12 |
| 2023/24 | New York City FC · 11th | 21 | 0 | 0 | 6.69 | 37 | 0 |
| 2022/23 | New York City FC · 3rd | 6 | 0 | 0 | 6.5 | 37 | 0 |
Domestic-league totals per season. RTG = Field Insider Rating (potential / ceiling); Season = age-blind form that year.
K. O'Toole is a 27-year-old full-back at New York City FC, rated 36.4 overall by Field Insider's model, ranking 299th of 790 in the Major League Soccer. In his prime years, he has been an ever-present this season (81.1% of available minutes). His defensive output reads 3.55 tackles, blocks and interceptions per 90. Below: strengths, watch-points, market-value outlook and the latest transfer news on O'Toole.
Judged on this season alone, O'Toole graded 37 — a standout campaign that ranks top 5% of the 135 full-backs in the Major League Soccer, on 8 clean sheets and 3.545 defensive actions per 90.
Year-on-year, that's a clear step up on last season (Season 12 → 37). Across the 4 seasons we hold, it's his best return yet.
On long-term talent our Rating reads 36, top 37% of the 135 full-backs in the Major League Soccer. At 27 O'Toole is in his prime years, and a market index of 18.9 reflects that trajectory.
Read the appearance count in context: O'Toole missed 6 games through injury and 1 suspension (leg) out of roughly 39 this season. The 29 he did play is a solid return on the time he was fit, and his ratings are weighted toward those games rather than the ones he sat out injured.
A career still climbing — O'Toole is at his peak right now, and the curve hasn't flattened.
3.55 tackles, blocks & interceptions per 90 — solid defensive volume, with 8 clean sheets across 29 appearances. Going forward he chipped in 1 goal and 1 assist — a useful bonus from the back.
With a Rating of 36.4, O'Toole carries the 49th-highest potential of the full-backs in the Major League Soccer (top 37%). Defensively he reads as solid defensive volume (3.55 tackles, blocks & interceptions per 90). In the prime window — at or near peak market value, so the next two seasons are the ones to cash in or build around.
Generated from Field Insider's rating model · AI-written analysis to follow.
The gold line is market value — an index (not €) blending rating, age and league. It climbs through the early 20s, peaks around ages 23–27 (~19), then tapers with age. At 27, O'Toole sits on 18.9, at or near its peak. The blue line is O'Toole's projected Rating — 36.4 today — recomputed at each age, so it follows the same rise-and-fall as a career matures and declines. Solid = up to today; dashed = projected.
No transfer news found for this player.
