Kevin O'Toole

O'Toole's current-season form is down 63% on last season (Season 30→11), while his Rating eased 35→33. His peak season for form remains 2025/26 (Season 30).

Domestic career

Season	Club	Apps	G	A	Match	RTG	Season
2026/27	New York City FC · 8th	13	0	0	6.34	33	20
2025/26	New York City FC · 8th	29	1	1	6.88	35	30
2024/25	New York City FC · 6th	34	1	2	6.88	43	12
2023/24	New York City FC · 11th	21	0	0	6.69	37	0
2022/23	New York City FC · 3rd	6	0	0	6.5	37	0

Domestic-league totals per season. RTG = Field Insider Rating (potential / ceiling); Season = age-blind form that year. 4 youth-team spells in the full career.

Scout report

Squad depthCentral defender

K. O'Toole is a 27-year-old central defender at New York City FC, rated 32.8 overall by Field Insider's model, ranking 256th of 436 on scout potential in the Major League Soccer. In his prime years, he has been a rotation option this season (55.3% of available minutes). His defensive output reads 2.07 tackles, blocks and interceptions per 90. Below: strengths, watch-points, market-value outlook and the latest transfer news on O'Toole.

Judged on this season alone, O'Toole graded 11 — a workmanlike campaign that ranks 57th of 101 of the 101 centre-backs in the Major League Soccer, on 2 clean sheets and 2.065 defensive actions per 90.

Year-on-year, that's a drop on last season (Season 30 → 11). Over the 5 seasons on record his form has trended upward, peaking in 2025/26.

On long-term talent our Rating reads 33, 52nd of 101 of the 101 centre-backs in the Major League Soccer. At 27 O'Toole is in his prime years, and a market index of 6.1 reflects that trajectory.

From the career report

Read the full career report →

Below his 2025/26 peak but holding a solid level — the platform for a return is there.

Peak: 2025/26Trending upBreakout: 2025/26Injury-hit 2025/26

Current potential52nd of 101 centre-backs · Major League Soccer · 13 apps Current season57th of 101 centre-backs · Major League Soccer · 13 apps 57th-best centre-back in the Major League Soccer 256th in the Major League Soccer · potential 52nd-highest potential centre-back in the Major League Soccer

32.8

Ratingi

52nd of 101 centre-backs

11.3

Seasoni

below regular-starter level

55.3%

Minutes

rotation minutes

2.07

Def. actions / 90

moderate defensive volume

Output in context · New York City FC finished 8th of 15 · a mid-table side

Apps

2.07

Def. / 90

Tackles

Interceptions

Clean sheets

2.07 tackles, blocks & interceptions per 90 — moderate defensive volume, with 2 clean sheets across 13 appearances.

Watch points

Game time. Only 55.3% of available minutes — needs a settled run to prove the level.
Level. Rates below a nailed-on top-tier starter on our model.

Outlook

With a Rating of 32.8, O'Toole carries the 52nd-highest potential of the centre-backs in the Major League Soccer of 101 — though on just 13 appearances this season, so the standing rests on a small sample. Defensively he reads as moderate defensive volume (2.07 tackles, blocks & interceptions per 90). In the prime window — at or near peak market value, so the next two seasons are the ones to cash in or build around.

Generated from Field Insider's rating model · AI-written analysis to follow.

Per 90 & availability

Minutes played %55.3%

Available fixtures21 of 21

Goals / 900

Assists / 900

Goal contribution / 900

Defensive actions / 902.065

Player flow

Goal involvements0

Shot conversion %0

Shot accuracy %66.7

Pass accuracy %88

Dribble success %20

Cards / 900

Foul involvement / 901.033

Season-by-season progression

Rating (potential)Season (form)

Value & potential by age

Market valueRating

Solid = now · dashed = projected

The gold line is market value — an index (not €) blending rating, age and league. It climbs through the early 20s, peaks around ages 23–27 (~6), then tapers with age. At 27, O'Toole sits on 6.1, at or near its peak. The blue line is O'Toole's projected Rating — 32.8 today — recomputed at each age, so it follows the same rise-and-fall as a career matures and declines. Solid = up to today; dashed = projected.

Season statistics

Bars = where he ranks among centre-backs in the Major League Soccer with 600+ minutes this season.

Shooting

Goals0

Shots on target2

Shots3

Passing

Assists0

Chances created5

Passes614

Pass accuracy88%

Possession

Successful dribbles2

Dribble success20%

Duels won33

Duels won %49.3%

Fouls won5

Defending

Tackles15

Interceptions5

Blocks4

Fouls committed7

Penalties conceded1

Yellow/red cards

Yellow cards0

Red cards0

About K. O'Toole

Kevin O'Toole is a 27-year-old centre-back who plays for New York City FC, born on December 14, 1998, standing 178 cm tall. He is from USA. New York City FC currently sit 8th of 15 in the Major League Soccer.

This season

In the current season, K. O'Toole has made 13 appearances with 0 goals and 0 assists across 1,046 minutes, averaging a 6.28 match rating over his last 10 rated games.

When K. O'Toole plays, New York City FC's record this season is 3W-4D-7L — and his match ratings average 6.31 at home against 6.41 on the road.

Recent matches

August 23, 2026: 1-1 draw away at New England Revolution (22 minutes, 6.5 rating)
August 19, 2026: 1-2 loss away at FC Cincinnati (75 minutes, 6.2 rating)
August 16, 2026: 2-3 loss at home vs Philadelphia Union (30 minutes, 6 rating)
August 9, 2026: 1-2 loss away at Cruz Azul (31 minutes, 6.7 rating)
April 25, 2026: 0-1 loss away at CF Montreal (90 minutes, 6.3 rating)
April 22, 2026: 4-4 draw at home vs FC Cincinnati (90 minutes, 5.2 rating)
April 18, 2026: 1-2 loss at home vs Charlotte (90 minutes, 6.7 rating)
April 11, 2026: 0-2 loss away at Vancouver Whitecaps (90 minutes, 6.6 rating)
April 4, 2026: 1-1 draw at home vs St. Louis City (90 minutes, 6.3 rating)
March 22, 2026: 2-3 loss at home vs Inter Miami (97 minutes, 6.3 rating)

K. O'Toole's next match is on August 29, 2026, when New York City FC face Toronto FC away in the Major League Soccer.

Field Insider's view

Field Insider currently rates K. O'Toole at 32.8 with a Season form score of 11.3, ranking 256th of 436 centre-backs in the Major League Soccer. See the full scout report for strengths, watch-points and the market-value outlook.

His honours include 4 career titles — among them the Campeones Cup and the USL Championship. Full list in the career record.

Career

Across 7 recorded seasons, K. O'Toole has totalled 139 club appearances with 3 goals and 3 assists for 3 different clubs. His busiest campaign came in 2024/25, with 34 appearances for New York City FC.

Transfer news

No transfer news found for this player.

Profile

Season stats

Performance data · by competition

Career

Scout report

Output in context · New York City FC finished 8th of 15 · a mid-table side

Watch points

Outlook

Per 90 & availability

Player flow

Season-by-season progression

Value & potential by age

Season statistics

Shooting

Passing

Possession

Defending

Yellow/red cards

About K. O'Toole

This season

Recent matches

Field Insider's view

Career

Transfer news

Related players

Career

Per 90 & availability

Player flow

Season-by-season progression

Value & potential by age

About K. O'Toole

This season

Recent matches

Field Insider's view

Career

Related players