Profile
Season stats
Full career & schedule →Domestic-league season · New York City FC.
Injury-affected season
Missed 7 of New York City FC's ~39 games this season through 6 injury absences and 1 suspension (leg). He still appeared 29 times — a solid return given how little of the season he was available. His rating is judged mainly on the games he was fit to play.
Performance data · by competition
| Competition | Apps | G | A | Min | Match |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Major League Soccer | 29 | 1 | 1 | 2336 | 6.88 |
 Leagues Cup | 3 | 0 | 0 | 180 | 7.05 |
Scout report
K. O'Toole is a 27-year-old full-back at New York City FC, enjoying a standout season — 1 goals and 1 assists in 29 appearances, a Season grade of 37, top 6% of Major League Soccer full-backs. On long-term scout potential he's rated 36.5, ranking 227th of 513 in the Major League Soccer. In his prime years, he has been an ever-present (81.1% of available minutes). His defensive output reads 3.55 tackles, blocks and interceptions per 90. Below: strengths, watch-points, market-value outlook and the latest transfer news on O'Toole.
Judged on this season alone, O'Toole graded 37 — an excellent campaign that ranks top 6% of the 101 full-backs in the Major League Soccer, on 8 clean sheets and 3.545 defensive actions per 90.
Year-on-year, that's a clear step up on last season (Season 12 → 37). Across the 4 seasons we hold, it's his best return yet.
On long-term talent our Rating reads 37, 41st of 101 of the 101 full-backs in the Major League Soccer. At 27 O'Toole is in his prime years, and a market index of 11.4 reflects that trajectory.
Read the appearance count in context: O'Toole missed 6 games through injury and 1 suspension (leg) out of roughly 39 this season. The 29 he did play is a solid return on the time he was fit, and his ratings are weighted toward those games rather than the ones he sat out injured.
A career still climbing — O'Toole is at his peak right now, and the curve hasn't flattened.
Output in context · New York City FC finished 10th of 20 · a mid-table side
3.55 tackles, blocks & interceptions per 90 — solid defensive volume, with 8 clean sheets across 29 appearances. Going forward he chipped in 1 goal and 1 assist — a useful bonus from the back.
Strengths
- Availability. On the pitch for 81.1% of available minutes — a dependable presence in the XI.
- Defensive volume. 3.55 tackles, blocks & interceptions per 90 — does the unseen work.
Watch points
- Level. Rates below a nailed-on top-tier starter on our model.
Outlook
With a Rating of 36.5, O'Toole carries the 41st-highest potential of the full-backs in the Major League Soccer of 101. Defensively he reads as solid defensive volume (3.55 tackles, blocks & interceptions per 90). In the prime window — at or near peak market value, so the next two seasons are the ones to cash in or build around.
Generated from Field Insider's rating model · AI-written analysis to follow.
Transfer news
No transfer news found for this player.
