Baumgartner has the better season, a 78 to Dimarco's 73 — a 5-point edge on our age-blind form rating. Baumgartner is posting 13G/8A and 2.549 defensive actions/90, against 7G/16A and 2.829 defensive actions/90 for Dimarco.

On talent/ceiling our Rating favours Baumgartner (84 to 70). At 26 vs 28, Baumgartner has more road ahead, which lifts his ceiling.

By market value, Baumgartner is the pricier asset (140.1 to 72.7). Year-on-year, Baumgartner (value 140.1, season +155.7% YoY) and Dimarco (value 72.7, season +94.9% YoY) — with Baumgartner on the pitch for 93.9% of available minutes to Dimarco's 81.2%.